Hi, @brokeyourbike, and welcome to our Netlify community site. Thank you as well for sharing your solution for this issue.
The DNS configuration was already deleted and recreated, so I’m not able to see the previous configuration. Because of this, I’m not sure why the DNS configuration wasn’t working before.
Possible reason for this include:
old DNS records being cached
an error at Netlify (rare but possible)
Again, I’m glad to learn it is working now. If there are other questions, we’re happy to answer.