Custom domain - DNS Zone already exists

I am trying to add a Custom Domain using a new GoDaddy domain: www.trustluigi.com.

When I setup Netlify DNS I get the error: “A DNS zone for this domain already exists on NS1”.

It is strange because the domain is using default godaddy nameserver:
ns33.domaincontrol.com
ns34.domaincontrol.com

What can I do?

Hi @fabio-C! Welcome to netlify community.

I will follow up with an email to verify some details and complete your request.